Close Menu
  • Home
  • AI Models
    • DeepSeek
    • xAI
    • OpenAI
    • Meta AI Llama
    • Google DeepMind
    • Amazon AWS AI
    • Microsoft AI
    • Anthropic (Claude)
    • NVIDIA AI
    • IBM WatsonX Granite 3.1
    • Adobe Sensi
    • Hugging Face
    • Alibaba Cloud (Qwen)
    • Baidu (ERNIE)
    • C3 AI
    • DataRobot
    • Mistral AI
    • Moonshot AI (Kimi)
    • Google Gemma
    • xAI
    • Stability AI
    • H20.ai
  • AI Research
    • Allen Institue for AI
    • arXiv AI
    • Berkeley AI Research
    • CMU AI
    • Google Research
    • Microsoft Research
    • Meta AI Research
    • OpenAI Research
    • Stanford HAI
    • MIT CSAIL
    • Harvard AI
  • AI Funding & Startups
    • AI Funding Database
    • CBInsights AI
    • Crunchbase AI
    • Data Robot Blog
    • TechCrunch AI
    • VentureBeat AI
    • The Information AI
    • Sifted AI
    • WIRED AI
    • Fortune AI
    • PitchBook
    • TechRepublic
    • SiliconANGLE – Big Data
    • MIT News
    • Data Robot Blog
  • Expert Insights & Videos
    • Google DeepMind
    • Lex Fridman
    • Matt Wolfe AI
    • Yannic Kilcher
    • Two Minute Papers
    • AI Explained
    • TheAIEdge
    • Matt Wolfe AI
    • The TechLead
    • Andrew Ng
    • OpenAI
  • Expert Blogs
    • François Chollet
    • Gary Marcus
    • IBM
    • Jack Clark
    • Jeremy Howard
    • Melanie Mitchell
    • Andrew Ng
    • Andrej Karpathy
    • Sebastian Ruder
    • Rachel Thomas
    • IBM
  • AI Policy & Ethics
    • ACLU AI
    • AI Now Institute
    • Center for AI Safety
    • EFF AI
    • European Commission AI
    • Partnership on AI
    • Stanford HAI Policy
    • Mozilla Foundation AI
    • Future of Life Institute
    • Center for AI Safety
    • World Economic Forum AI
  • AI Tools & Product Releases
    • AI Assistants
    • AI for Recruitment
    • AI Search
    • Coding Assistants
    • Customer Service AI
    • Image Generation
    • Video Generation
    • Writing Tools
    • AI for Recruitment
    • Voice/Audio Generation
  • Industry Applications
    • Finance AI
    • Healthcare AI
    • Legal AI
    • Manufacturing AI
    • Media & Entertainment
    • Transportation AI
    • Education AI
    • Retail AI
    • Agriculture AI
    • Energy AI
  • AI Art & Entertainment
    • AI Art News Blog
    • Artvy Blog » AI Art Blog
    • Weird Wonderful AI Art Blog
    • The Chainsaw » AI Art
    • Artvy Blog » AI Art Blog
What's Hot

AI investments failing? 95 per cent of firms see no returns, says MIT | Technology News

Canva prototypes faster with GPT-5

ElevenLabs Releases Eleven v3 (Alpha) API for Advanced AI Voice Synthesis Development | AI News Detail

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Advanced AI News
  • Home
  • AI Models
    • OpenAI (GPT-4 / GPT-4o)
    • Anthropic (Claude 3)
    • Google DeepMind (Gemini)
    • Meta (LLaMA)
    • Cohere (Command R)
    • Amazon (Titan)
    • IBM (Watsonx)
    • Inflection AI (Pi)
  • AI Research
    • Allen Institue for AI
    • arXiv AI
    • Berkeley AI Research
    • CMU AI
    • Google Research
    • Meta AI Research
    • Microsoft Research
    • OpenAI Research
    • Stanford HAI
    • MIT CSAIL
    • Harvard AI
  • AI Funding
    • AI Funding Database
    • CBInsights AI
    • Crunchbase AI
    • Data Robot Blog
    • TechCrunch AI
    • VentureBeat AI
    • The Information AI
    • Sifted AI
    • WIRED AI
    • Fortune AI
    • PitchBook
    • TechRepublic
    • SiliconANGLE – Big Data
    • MIT News
    • Data Robot Blog
  • AI Experts
    • Google DeepMind
    • Lex Fridman
    • Meta AI Llama
    • Yannic Kilcher
    • Two Minute Papers
    • AI Explained
    • TheAIEdge
    • The TechLead
    • Matt Wolfe AI
    • Andrew Ng
    • OpenAI
    • Expert Blogs
      • François Chollet
      • Gary Marcus
      • IBM
      • Jack Clark
      • Jeremy Howard
      • Melanie Mitchell
      • Andrew Ng
      • Andrej Karpathy
      • Sebastian Ruder
      • Rachel Thomas
      • IBM
  • AI Tools
    • AI Assistants
    • AI for Recruitment
    • AI Search
    • Coding Assistants
    • Customer Service AI
  • AI Policy
    • ACLU AI
    • AI Now Institute
    • Center for AI Safety
  • Business AI
    • Advanced AI News Features
    • Finance AI
    • Healthcare AI
    • Education AI
    • Energy AI
    • Legal AI
LinkedIn Instagram YouTube Threads X (Twitter)
Advanced AI News
arXiv AI

A Comment On "The Illusion of Thinking": Reframing the Reasoning Cliff as an Agentic Gap

By Advanced AI EditorJune 26, 2025No Comments2 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Copy Link Telegram LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email



arXiv:2506.18957v1 Announce Type: new
Abstract: The recent work by Shojaee et al. (2025), titled The Illusion of Thinking: Understanding the Strengths and Limitations of Reasoning Models via the Lens of Problem Complexity, presents a compelling empirical finding, a reasoning cliff, where the performance of Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) collapses beyond a specific complexity threshold, which the authors posit as an intrinsic scaling limitation of Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning. This commentary, while acknowledging the study’s methodological rigor, contends that this conclusion is confounded by experimental artifacts. We argue that the observed failure is not evidence of a fundamental cognitive boundary, but rather a predictable outcome of system-level constraints in the static, text-only evaluation paradigm, including tool use restrictions, context window recall issues, the absence of crucial cognitive baselines, inadequate statistical reporting, and output generation limits. We reframe this performance collapse through the lens of an agentic gap, asserting that the models are not failing at reasoning, but at execution within a profoundly restrictive interface. We empirically substantiate this critique by demonstrating a striking reversal. A model, initially declaring a puzzle impossible when confined to text-only generation, now employs agentic tools to not only solve it but also master variations of complexity far beyond the reasoning cliff it previously failed to surmount. Additionally, our empirical analysis of tool-enabled models like o4-mini and GPT-4o reveals a hierarchy of agentic reasoning, from simple procedural execution to complex meta-cognitive self-correction, which has significant implications for how we define and measure machine intelligence. The illusion of thinking attributed to LRMs is less a reasoning deficit and more a consequence of an otherwise capable mind lacking the tools for action.



Source link

Follow on Google News Follow on Flipboard
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link
Previous ArticleBoston Consulting Group: To unlock enterprise AI value, start with the data you’ve been ignoring
Next Article China-tied AI tools like DeepSeek face US federal ban over ‘threat’ to national security
Advanced AI Editor
  • Website

Related Posts

LTLCrit: A Temporal Logic-based LLM Critic for Safe and Efficient Embodied Agents

July 8, 2025

From Imitation to Innovation: The Emergence of AI Unique Artistic Styles and the Challenge of Copyright Protection

July 8, 2025

VerifyLLM: LLM-Based Pre-Execution Task Plan Verification for Robots

July 8, 2025
Leave A Reply

Latest Posts

Tanya Bonakdar Gallery to Close Los Angeles Space

Ancient Silver Coins Suggest New History of Trading in Southeast Asia

Sasan Ghandehari Sues Christie’s Over Picasso Once Owned by a Criminal

Dallas Museum of Art Names Brian Ferriso as Its Next Director

Latest Posts

AI investments failing? 95 per cent of firms see no returns, says MIT | Technology News

August 21, 2025

Canva prototypes faster with GPT-5

August 21, 2025

ElevenLabs Releases Eleven v3 (Alpha) API for Advanced AI Voice Synthesis Development | AI News Detail

August 21, 2025

Subscribe to News

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news

Subscribe my Newsletter for New Posts & tips Let's stay updated!

Recent Posts

  • AI investments failing? 95 per cent of firms see no returns, says MIT | Technology News
  • Canva prototypes faster with GPT-5
  • ElevenLabs Releases Eleven v3 (Alpha) API for Advanced AI Voice Synthesis Development | AI News Detail
  • SpotDraft, StructureFlow, BigHand, Eudia + ClausePilot – Artificial Lawyer
  • C3.AI Stock Is Surging Tuesday: What’s Going On? – C3.ai (NYSE:AI)

Recent Comments

  1. Binance Paglikha ng Account on Google’s Sergey Brin: ‘I made a lot of mistakes with Google Glass’
  2. Richardsmeap on 1-800-CHAT-GPT—12 Days of OpenAI: Day 10
  3. JuliusRex on 1-800-CHAT-GPT—12 Days of OpenAI: Day 10
  4. NathanFairl on 1-800-CHAT-GPT—12 Days of OpenAI: Day 10
  5. ocenochnaya-kompaniya-615 on 1-800-CHAT-GPT—12 Days of OpenAI: Day 10

Welcome to Advanced AI News—your ultimate destination for the latest advancements, insights, and breakthroughs in artificial intelligence.

At Advanced AI News, we are passionate about keeping you informed on the cutting edge of AI technology, from groundbreaking research to emerging startups, expert insights, and real-world applications. Our mission is to deliver high-quality, up-to-date, and insightful content that empowers AI enthusiasts, professionals, and businesses to stay ahead in this fast-evolving field.

Subscribe to Updates

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news

Subscribe my Newsletter for New Posts & tips Let's stay updated!

LinkedIn Instagram YouTube Threads X (Twitter)
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
© 2025 advancedainews. Designed by advancedainews.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.